“AFTER 28 YEARS, THE EAGLES RETURNED — AND THE LEAD VOICE WASN’T WHO ANYONE EXPECTED.” When the Eagles finally released a new studio album in 2007, ending a 28-year gap since The Long Run, fans expected Don Henley or Glenn Frey to take center stage. Instead, bassist Timothy B. Schmit stepped forward, delivering the lead vocal on a surprising cover written by English hitmaker Paul Carrack. Recorded across sessions from 2001 to 2007, the track became a standout moment — not just a comeback, but a shift in spotlight. Carrack had already released his own version earlier that year, with Henley and Schmit contributing backing vocals, creating a rare crossover between songwriter and band. Released to radio in 2009 as one of the album’s later singles, it marked a late-era Eagles moment where Schmit finally stood front and center. Want to hear how the quiet voice of the band took the lead?
“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.” Introduction I Don’t...